Select Page

REVUE LIMITE — MÉTAUX RARES ET GROS MENSONGES : LA FACE CACHÉE DES HIGH TECH / RARE METALS AND BIG LIES: THE HIDDEN SIDE OF HIGH TECH

REVUE LIMITE — MÉTAUX RARES ET GROS MENSONGES : LA FACE CACHÉE DES HIGH TECH / RARE METALS AND BIG LIES: THE HIDDEN SIDE OF HIGH TECH
Advertisement

La guerre des métaux rares, Guil­laume Pitron, Les Liens qui libèrent, Jan­u­ary 2018.

Noth­ing is more pol­lut­ing than new tech­nolo­gies. By mag­ni­fy­ing the line a lit­tle, that is how we could sum­ma­rize the very impor­tant sur­vey recent­ly pub­lished by Guil­laume Pitron. In La Guerre des métaux rares (Les Liens qui libèrent, Jan­u­ary 2018), he shows that green techs are far from being the panacea we are sold. This “counter-his­to­ry of the com­ing world”, pref­aced by Hubert Védrine, opens our eyes to the “hid­den side” of an ener­gy and dig­i­tal tran­si­tion that we pre­fer to ignore.

Oil of the 21st century?

The pro­po­nents of “sus­tain­able cap­i­tal­ism” promise us a world that is both more tech­no­log­i­cal and clean­er, where human inge­nu­ity would mit­i­gate cli­mate change, resource scarci­ty and ecosys­tem destruc­tion. The ener­gy tran­si­tion claims to replace fos­sil fuels with “green” ener­gies and the dig­i­tal tran­si­tion, by dema­te­ri­al­iz­ing exchanges, would pro­mote a less pol­lut­ing world. The real­i­ty is unfor­tu­nate­ly a lit­tle more complicated.

The first indus­tri­al rev­o­lu­tion in the 19th cen­tu­ry was based on the steam engine, itself depen­dent on an indis­pens­able fuel: coal. In the 20th cen­tu­ry, it was the com­bus­tion engine that enabled the sec­ond indus­tri­al rev­o­lu­tion thanks to the extrac­tion of oil. And now, at the begin­ning of the 21st cen­tu­ry, a third indus­tri­al rev­o­lu­tion has begun, with­out the ener­gy that con­di­tions it being known.

Graphite, cobalt, indi­um, plati­noids, tung­sten, rare earths… does­n’t ring a bell? Yet the con­nect­ed objects we use every day are full of them.” For a long time, peo­ple have exploit­ed the main met­als known to all: iron, gold, sil­ver, cop­per, lead, alu­mini­um… “We no longer know what the new tech­nolo­gies on which we have become depen­dent work. Unknown to the gen­er­al pub­lic, but exploit­ed since the 1970s, this “next oil” is the “fab­u­lous mag­net­ic and chem­i­cal prop­er­ties of a mul­ti­tude of small rare met­als con­tained in earth rocks”. Would this car­bon-free ener­gy, and there­fore much less pol­lut­ing, be the sal­va­tion of humanity?

“A plague become global”

Noth­ing is less cer­tain, because these indis­pens­able “rare met­als” are as dirty as… rare. They are in fact already the object of rival­ries and geopo­lit­i­cal ten­sions that we do not sus­pect: the “war of rare met­als” has only just begun. We already con­sume more than two bil­lion tons of var­i­ous met­als each year[and] stud­ies pre­dict that, by 2030, demand for ger­ma­ni­um will dou­ble, demand for dys­pro­sium and tan­ta­lum will quadru­ple, and demand for pal­la­di­um will quin­tu­ple. The sca­di­um mar­ket could be mul­ti­plied by 9, and the cobalt mar­ket by… 24!” (p. 39).

Guil­laume Pitron first takes us to Chi­na, the world’s lead­ing pro­duc­er of rare met­als, and espe­cial­ly rare earths, the most pre­cious of them, to inves­ti­gate the eco­log­i­cal and social dam­age caused by their extrac­tion. While becom­ing ubiq­ui­tous in the most excit­ing’­green’ and dig­i­tal tech­nolo­gies, rare met­als have also per­me­at­ed their high­ly tox­ic slag into the water, earth, atmos­phere and even the flames of blast fur­naces — the four ele­ments nec­es­sary for life” (p. 44). The Chi­nese peo­ple have sac­ri­ficed their envi­ron­ment to feed the entire plan­et with rare earths,” con­cludes a Chi­nese expert with grav­i­ty (p. 48). Guil­laume Pitron shows that, far from being the bless­ing hoped for, the indus­tri­al exploita­tion of rare met­als has become a “scourge”.

But Chi­na is far from being the only coun­try affect­ed by this “curse”. Indeed, “extract­ing min­er­als from the ground is an intrin­si­cal­ly dirty activ­i­ty and so far it has been con­duct­ed in such a man­ner that the vir­tu­ous pur­pose of the ener­gy and dig­i­tal tran­si­tion is nec­es­sar­i­ly called into ques­tion”. While the petro­chem­i­cal indus­try “which every­one is try­ing to get rid of, is not even in the top ten”, “min­ing is the sec­ond most pol­lut­ing indus­try in the world”, “behind lead bat­tery recy­cling and ahead of dye­ing, indus­tri­al land­fills and tan­ner­ies” (p. 54).

“A damning ecological balance sheet”

In short, “even before they are put into ser­vice, a solar pan­el, a wind tur­bine, an elec­tric car or a low-ener­gy lamp bear the orig­i­nal sin of their deplorable ener­gy and envi­ron­men­tal bal­ance” (p. 55). In real­i­ty, if we take into account the entire pro­duc­tion process since the extrac­tion of the man­u­fac­tur­ing ele­ments, and not only the oper­a­tion itself, green tech­nolo­gies have a “damn­ing eco­log­i­cal bal­ance” (p. 58). For exam­ple, “the indus­tri­al­iza­tion of an elec­tric car alone con­sumes three to four times more ener­gy than that of a con­ven­tion­al vehicle.

This does not include all the dis­eases gen­er­at­ed among work­ers and res­i­dents of min­ing infrastructures.

In oth­er words, accord­ing to Guil­laume Pitron, the rem­e­dy (rare met­als) could prove to be worse than the evil (oil) it was sup­posed to cure… Thus pro­duc­tivism, even repaint­ed green, makes us fall from Charyb­dis to Scyl­la, “a bit like a drug addict who, to stop his addic­tion to cocaine, would sink into hero­in”. Basi­cal­ly, we are not address­ing the chal­lenge of the impact of human activ­i­ty on ecosys­tems; we are sim­ply shift­ing it” (p.70).

Always more: the indus­tri­al flight for­ward, and the destruc­tion of the world it gen­er­ates, will only inten­si­fy with the high­ly pol­lut­ing extrac­tion of rare met­als. We will con­sume more min­er­als in the next gen­er­a­tion than in the last 70,000 years, the 500 gen­er­a­tions before us” (p. 214). And it is not COP21, focus­ing on the harm­ful effects of oil, that will lim­it the dam­age caused.

How­ev­er, in addi­tion to envi­ron­men­tal and health dis­as­ters, there are eco­nom­ic and geopo­lit­i­cal strug­gles for con­trol over resources and technologies.

Chinese revenge

The rest of the book shows how the West, and France in par­tic­u­lar, has pre­ferred to “relo­cate pollution”“to poor coun­tries will­ing to sac­ri­fice their environment[and their pop­u­la­tion] to enrich them­selves” rather than to assume the cost of an eco­log­i­cal­ly and social­ly sus­tain­able extrac­tion. It thus details the trans­fer of tech­ni­cal skills from a large indus­try such as Rhône-Poulenc, and the aban­don­ment of pub­lic poli­cies of “min­er­al sov­er­eign­ty”. We have gained in pur­chas­ing pow­er what we have lost in pur­chas­ing knowl­edge,” notes Guil­laume Pitron. But this choice is like­ly to cost us dear­ly: “By orga­niz­ing the trans­fer of rare met­al pro­duc­tion, we have done much more than leave the bur­den of 21st cen­tu­ry oil to the forces of glob­al­iza­tion, we have entrust­ed poten­tial rivals with a pre­cious monop­oly” (p. 116).

And Chi­na, which has tak­en 99% of the world’s rare earth pro­duc­tion for itself, has already begun to take advan­tage of this sit­u­a­tion by plac­ing “the West under embar­go”. And it not only con­fis­cates rare met­als, it trans­forms them to make “low hand on high tech­nolo­gies”. It has set up “a com­plete­ly sov­er­eign and inte­grat­ed sec­tor, which encom­pass­es both smelly mines sur­veyed by black gules and ultra-mod­ern fac­to­ries pop­u­lat­ed by over­grad­u­at­ed engi­neers” (p. 155). Thus, Chi­na has become “the world’s lead­ing pro­duc­er of green ener­gy, the lead­ing man­u­fac­tur­er of pho­to­volta­ic equip­ment, the lead­ing hydro­elec­tric pow­er, the lead­ing investor in wind pow­er and the world’s lead­ing mar­ket for new ener­gy cars” (p. 176), while France has lost 900,000 indus­tri­al jobs in the last fif­teen years (p. 183).

How­ev­er, Guil­laume Pitron recalls, “each time a peo­ple has mas­tered a new met­al, its use has been accom­pa­nied by tremen­dous tech­ni­cal and mil­i­tary progress — and ever more dead­ly con­flicts” (p.192). And he takes as an exam­ple “the race for intel­li­gent mis­siles” and the con­quest of the oceans, which con­tain immense deposits of rare metals.

Relocate and/or decrease?

Faced with this sit­u­a­tion, Guil­laume Pitron rec­om­mend­ed relo­cat­ing our min­ing activ­i­ties. A rein­dus­tri­al­iza­tion of France, then. Not so much to counter Chi­nese impe­ri­al­ism and not to find our­selves com­plete­ly dis­armed in this “war of rare met­als” as to fos­ter the emer­gence of a tru­ly eco­log­i­cal soci­ety. Noth­ing will change rad­i­cal­ly until we expe­ri­ence, under our win­dows, the total cost of our stan­dard hap­pi­ness. The respon­si­ble mine here will always be bet­ter than the irre­spon­si­ble mine elsewhere.”

Guil­laume Pitron’s sur­vey, which evokes “degrowth” with­out advo­cat­ing it, ends with a ques­tion in the form of hope: “Will we know how to draw from our­selves the anti­dote to rare metals?

No mat­ter how much we take the prob­lem, and what we call this “escape route” of sobri­ety or decline, the pro­found sim­pli­fi­ca­tion of our lifestyles appears more and more as a vital neces­si­ty and a con­di­tion for peace.

In any case, after read­ing this excit­ing book, you will no longer see your smart­phone in the same way. And if that makes you want to do with­out it (which is not that dif­fi­cult!), it will be one less weapon in this mer­ci­less war of human­i­ty against itself.

 

Gaulti­er Bès
Assis­tant Direc­tor of Lim­ite magazine

ADLAUDATOSI INTEGRAL ECOLOGY FORUM WEBINARS

OUR MISSION:

THE PURPOSE IS TO SHARE BEST PRACTICES AND PROMOTE ACTIONS AGAINST HUMAN TRAFFICKING.

WE MAKE AVAILABLE TO YOU GUIDES AND RESEARCH ON TRAFFICKING IN HUMAN BEINGS FROM THE MOST RECOGNISED LEGAL AND OPERATIONAL ACTORS.

Human Trafficking — Interview with Prof. Michel Veuthey, Order of Malta — 44th UN Human Right Council 2020

POPE’S PAYER INTENTION FOR FEBRUARY 2020: Hear the cries of migrants victims of human trafficking

FRANCE — BLOG DU COLLECTIF “CONTRE LA TRAITE DES ÊTRES HUMAINS”

Church on the frontlines in fight against human trafficking

Holy See — PUBLICATION OF PASTORAL ORIENTATIONS ON HUMAN TRAFFICKING 2019

RIGHT TO LIFE AND HUMAN DIGNITY GUIDEBOOK

Catholic social teaching

Doctrine sociale de l’Église catholique

That Moment Your Inner Activist Awakens: Nobel Peace Prize winner Kailash Satyarthi

Pope Francis joins religious leaders of different faiths, in fight against modern slavery

Michel Veuthey talks about the Order of Malta’s involvement in fighting human trafficking

Register to our series of webinars adlaudatosi on Human Trafficking

 
 

You have successfully registered !