Select Page

01.- Therapie germinale / Germinal Therapy — CHURCH OF FRANCE — États généraux de la bioéthique — Which world do we want for tomorrow? The brave new world…

01.- Therapie germinale / Germinal Therapy — CHURCH OF FRANCE — États généraux de la bioéthique — Which world do we want for tomorrow? The brave new world…
Advertisement

Scientific and legal elements :

There are two types of gene ther­a­py: somat­ic and germline.
Somat­ic gene ther­a­py con­sists in act­ing on cer­tain non-repro­duc­tive cells to elim­i­nate or reduce genet­ic defects. The effects are lim­it­ed to the indi­vid­ual treat­ed. Clin­i­cal tri­als are under­way with some suc­cess in rela­tion to sick­le cell dis­ease (genet­ic dis­ease of the blood) or cer­tain forms of leukaemia.

Germ-line gene ther­a­py involves mod­i­fy­ing a gene so that it is then trans­mit­ted to the sub­jec­t’s off­spring. This can be done in two ways:

  • either on a very young embryo at the zygote stage[1],
  • either on germ cells (gamete pro­duc­ers) or gametes (sperm and eggs) dur­ing their formation.

The embryo or gametes on which the research is being con­duct­ed are cur­rent­ly manip­u­lat­ed in vit­ro. Male gametes are removed by mas­tur­ba­tion and female gametes are removed by punc­ture after hor­mon­al stim­u­la­tion. Inter­ven­tion on gamete or embryo DNA is per­formed by insert­ing, cor­rect­ing or remov­ing a small, well-defined seg­ment of DNA (CRISPR-Case technique9). This results in a change in the genome of the embryo or future embryo, which is poten­tial­ly trans­mis­si­ble. In the long term, the genet­ic her­itage of the human species could be grad­u­al­ly modified.

Remem­ber that the gamete for­ma­tion process (“mei­ot­ic recom­bi­na­tion”) results, on the one hand, in an indi­vid­u­al’s germ cells not hav­ing the same genet­ic sequence as that of his somat­ic cells, and, on the oth­er hand, in each gamete hav­ing a unique genet­ic code.

If we also take into account the fact that the vast major­i­ty of dis­eases “depend on many genes as well as envi­ron­men­tal fac­tors and lifestyles,[2]” we under­stand that genet­ic engi­neer­ing can­not be an easy solu­tion for treat­ing most dis­eases. How­ev­er, CRISPR-Cas9 appli­ca­tion research in mice has shown promis­ing results in the treat­ment of Duchenne mus­cu­lar dystrophy.

Legal­ly, Arti­cle 13 of the Oviedo Con­ven­tion, rat­i­fied by France, stip­u­lates that “an inter­ven­tion intend­ed to mod­i­fy the human genome may be under­tak­en only for pre­ven­tive, diag­nos­tic or ther­a­peu­tic rea­sons, and only if it is not intend­ed to intro­duce a mod­i­fi­ca­tion in the genome of the descen­dants”. Ger­mi­nal gene ther­a­py is there­fore pro­hib­it­ed in France today.

How­ev­er, the Acad­e­my of Med­i­cine has pro­posed autho­riz­ing research on germ cells and embryos “when sci­en­tif­i­cal­ly and med­ical­ly justified.

Anthropological and Ethical Issues

As Pope Fran­cis recalled, if tech­nique, well direct­ed, can “pro­duce tru­ly pre­cious things for the qual­i­ty of life of the human being”, it can also give us “a ter­ri­ble pow­er”, even “an impres­sive hold over the whole of humanity[4]”. Germ-line gene ther­a­py expos­es to such a risk. Here are four points of discernment.
1. Gen­er­al prin­ci­ple of pre­cau­tion: “We still know too lit­tle about genet­ic inter­ac­tions and the pos­si­ble unin­tend­ed con­se­quences of the mod­i­fi­ca­tion of the human genome. By elim­i­nat­ing some harm­ful pre­dis­po­si­tions, oth­er prob­lems could appear and expose indi­vid­u­als and the human species itself to oth­er risks poten­tial­ly as seri­ous as those we could solve.

2. Respect for the most vul­ner­a­ble: pru­dence calls for inter­na­tion­al reg­u­la­tion of research and its appli­ca­tions to guar­an­tee, in par­tic­u­lar, “respect for vul­ner­a­ble per­sons and per­son­al integri­ty”, “non-dis­crim­i­na­tion and non-stigma­ti­za­tion” and “pro­tec­tion of future generations[6]”. On the lat­ter cri­te­ri­on, it should be not­ed that the mod­i­fi­ca­tion of the genet­ic her­itage of gametes or human embryos in the very ear­ly stages of their growth would have con­se­quences for the whole lives of future chil­dren. By touch­ing the genet­ic struc­ture of their body, it is their free devel­op­ment that is conditioned[7].

3. Banal­iza­tion of gametes and embryo com­mod­i­fi­ca­tion: gametes are col­lect­ed and manip­u­lat­ed out­side any con­ju­gal rela­tion­ship. As far as embryos are con­cerned, both research and the appli­ca­tion of gene ther­a­py are car­ried out with­in the tech­ni­cal frame­work of in vit­ro fer­til­i­sa­tion. This means that human embryos will be han­dled, frozen, sort­ed and some destroyed. The human embryo is there­fore chosi­fied until destruction.

4. Eugen­ics: “Such manip­u­la­tions pro­mote an eugenic men­tal­i­ty and intro­duce an indi­rect social stigma­ti­za­tion towards those who do not pos­sess cer­tain par­tic­u­lar qual­i­ties. These manip­u­la­tions raise the for­mi­da­ble ques­tion of “who would deter­mine which of these mod­i­fi­ca­tions would be pos­i­tive and which would not[8]”.

While somat­ic gene ther­a­py can be wel­comed as a promis­ing advance, sub­ject to the pre­cau­tions com­mon to all research and ther­a­peu­tic pro­to­cols, germline gene ther­a­py rais­es seri­ous eth­i­cal ques­tions, already expressed by some mem­bers of the inter­na­tion­al sci­en­tif­ic community.

The pro­posed dif­fer­ence between free­dom of research and con­trol of appli­ca­tions ignores the anthro­po­log­i­cal issues under­ly­ing sci­en­tif­ic research and tends to sub­or­di­nate ethics sole­ly to the cri­te­ri­on of effec­tive­ness. For the rea­sons stat­ed above, we can say that germline gene ther­a­py today does not offer the qual­i­ties nec­es­sary for ther­a­peu­tic action respect­ful of human dig­ni­ty and equal­i­ty between men.

Feb­ru­ary 1, 2018

 


[1] Cel­lule résul­tant de la fusion d’un sper­ma­to­zoïde et d’un ovule. Pre­mier stade de la vie d’un individu.
[2] Comité Inter­na­tion­al de Bioéthique de l’UNESCO, Rap­port du CIB sur la mise à jour de sa réflex­ion sur le génome humain et les droits de l’homme, 2015, n°103.
[3] Académie Nationale de Médecine, Rap­port « Mod­i­fi­ca­tions du génome des cel­lules ger­mi­nales et de l’embryon humain », 12 avril 2016.
[4] FRANÇOIS, Let­tre ency­clique Lauda­to Si’, 2015, n°103–104.
[5] UNESCO, Rap­port du CIB…, n°105.
[6] UNESCO, Rap­port du CIB…, n°116.
[7] Cf. J. HABERMAS, L’avenir de la nature humaine. Vers un eugénisme libéral ?, Gal­li­mard, 2002,
[8] CONGRÉGATION POUR LA DOCTRINE DE LA FOI, Instruc­tion « Dig­ni­tas Per­son­ae » sur cer­taines ques­tions de bioéthique, 2008, n°27.

ADLAUDATOSI INTEGRAL ECOLOGY FORUM WEBINARS

Religious Helping Trafficking Victims along the Road of Recovery (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

Religious Working In International Advocacy Against Human Trafficking (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

Impact Of Human Trafficking On Health: Trauma (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

Impact Of Human Trafficking On Health: Healing (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

International Prosecution Of Human Trafficking — Where Are We Now? (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

International Prosecution Of Human Trafficking — What can be done? (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

International Prosecution Of Human Trafficking — Best Practices (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

Demand As Root Cause For Human Trafficking – Sex Trafficking & Prostitution

OUR MISSION:

THE PURPOSE IS TO SHARE BEST PRACTICES AND PROMOTE ACTIONS AGAINST HUMAN TRAFFICKING.

WE MAKE AVAILABLE TO YOU GUIDES AND RESEARCH ON TRAFFICKING IN HUMAN BEINGS FROM THE MOST RECOGNISED LEGAL AND OPERATIONAL ACTORS.

Human Trafficking — Interview with Prof. Michel Veuthey, Order of Malta — 44th UN Human Right Council 2020

POPE’S PAYER INTENTION FOR FEBRUARY 2020: Hear the cries of migrants victims of human trafficking

FRANCE — BLOG DU COLLECTIF “CONTRE LA TRAITE DES ÊTRES HUMAINS”

Church on the frontlines in fight against human trafficking

Holy See — PUBLICATION OF PASTORAL ORIENTATIONS ON HUMAN TRAFFICKING 2019

RIGHT TO LIFE AND HUMAN DIGNITY GUIDEBOOK

Catholic social teaching

Doctrine sociale de l’Église catholique

Register to our series of webinars adlaudatosi on Human Trafficking

 
 

You have successfully registered !