Select Page

VINCENT COCHETEL’S PRESENTATION ON at the growing gap between the renewed political calls suggesting that more is being done against human traffickers … and the reality

VINCENT COCHETEL’S PRESENTATION ON at the growing gap between the renewed political calls suggesting that more is being done against human traffickers … and the reality

TRANSCRIPTS OF VINCENT COCHETEL’S PRESENTATION 

DECEMBER 11, 2023 SIDE EVENT 

AT PALAIS DES NATIONS UN GENEVA

 

REFUGEE PROTECTION AND HUMAN TRAFFICKING: AN IMPORTANT ISSUE FOR THE GLOBAL REFUGEE FORUM 2023

 
VINCENT COCHETEL: Ladies and gen­tle­men, thank you for this oppor­tu­ni­ty to share with you today, three obser­va­tions, to be very practical.

1.- The first thing I’d like to share with you is what I heard from the first vic­tim of traf­fick­ing, on this dai­ly route lead­ing to the cen­tral Mediter­ranean Sea that I met… It was silence! And that silence meant more than any spo­ken word. That silence com­mu­ni­cat­ed the chal­lenges of estab­lish­ing a mean­ing­ful, respect­ful, and effec­tive com­mu­ni­ca­tion with a vic­tim of traf­fick­ing. The young man from Mali had been lit­er­al­ly enslaved for almost two years by his traf­fick­ers. He was shack­led almost most of the time. And sub­ject to var­i­ous forms of tor­tures and depri­va­tion. His silence com­mu­ni­cat­ed his fear… But it also remind­ed me that trust can­not be assumed. It takes time, needs to be built. And it works dif­fer­ent­ly with dif­fer­ent peo­ple. Based on their cul­ture, age, gen­der, expe­ri­ence, trau­ma. It took him maybe 15 min­utes to move his eyes from his shoes to meet mine. His look expressed fear as he was full at arm’s length of his tor­tur­er. The first meet­ing was almost entire­ly non­ver­bal. On the while I let, the shared silence between us, on the cup of tea cre­ate a zone of com­fort, my mind focused on the refer­rals to be made. Yet between what was on the glossy paper of the nation­al refer­ral mech­a­nism for vic­tims of traf­fick­ing, on what ser­vices actu­al­ly were avail­able, there was a huge gap! Vic­tim response with­out pro­tec­tion means noth­ing… On whether the per­son was a refugee or migrant, did not real­ly have any rel­e­vance at this point. The per­son need­ed phys­i­cal, legal, social pro­tec­tion. The first thing I looked for was shel­ter in the nation­al refer­ral mech­a­nism and book. The first one did not exist in real­i­ty. The next one was school. The third one was too far on men trav­el­ing with risk of being undoc­u­ment­ed. And I looked for coun­sel­ing. The spe­cial­ized coun­sel­ing for this per­son was not imme­di­ate­ly avail­able, on the local NGO run­ning, it had no inter­preters for the lan­guage the per­son spoke. Third, med­ical care. Access to med­ical care was impos­si­ble due  to the lack of doc­u­men­ta­tion on gap in the nation­al leg­is­la­tion. And I could go on, go on, and go on… And that’s the expe­ri­ence I have in many of those African coun­tries on these routes lead­ing to the cen­tral Mediter­ranean Sea.

2.- The sec­ond obser­va­tion I’d like to share. Is my frus­tra­tion at the grow­ing gap between the renewed polit­i­cal calls sug­gest­ing that more is being done against human traf­fick­ers …—and the real­i­ty I know, at least on the route where I work. It might be dif­fer­ent in the con­text of the Ukraine sit­u­a­tion. The UNODC annu­al report breaks its load of depress­ing sta­tis­tics: one of them always strikes me, is about the decreas­ing pros­e­cu­tion on con­vic­tion rates for human traf­fick­ers. How often have we heard we need to defeat the busi­ness mod­el of the human traf­fick­ers, but are we mak­ing progress? Do we con­sid­er this crime as seri­ous­ly as we con­sid­er drug traf­fick­ing or arms traf­fick­ing? Do we fol­low mon­ey flows? Do we effec­tive­ly use exist­ing sanc­tion regime? Do we capac­i­tate ade­quate­ly judi­cial author­i­ties in this area? Do we rec­og­nize vic­tim of traf­fick­ing as right hold­ers and as poten­tial key assets for effec­tive pros­e­cu­tion? I leave you the answer. My con­cern also relates to the grow­ing gap between capac­i­ty build­ing efforts and vic­tims assis­tance in this field: a recent report from the UN sys­tem in March 2023 doc­u­ment­ed that most of the fund­ing relat­ing to human traf­fick­ing go towards data col­lec­tion, research, soft capac­i­ty build­ing activ­i­ties. I’m not say­ing it’s not need­ed, but efforts need to be bet­ter bal­anced with pre­dicts, such efforts need to be bet­ter bal­anced with pre­dictable vic­tims assis­tance. UNHR will pub­lish in Jan­u­ary 2024 a report show­ing that in 16 African coun­tries along the route I cov­ered, ser­vices for vic­tim of traf­fick­ing are not avail­able where they are most need­ed, such as in bor­der areas or in crit­i­cal mixed move­ment hubs where the risks are the most acute. Worse! This report updates the study we pub­lished two years ago, and it reveals that some of the ser­vices for vic­tims have now dis­ap­peared due to the lack of sup­port. This is par­tic­u­lar­ly the case for access to psy­choso­cial coun­sel­ing and access to jus­tice. And because of the lack of alter­na­tive solu­tions and sup­port, a for­eign vic­tim of traf­fick­ing which is not a refugee, is often just quick­ly sent back home, irre­spec­tive of the risk of retraf­fit­ing and with­out any form of access to justice.

3.- Final­ly, the third obser­va­tion I’d like to make is my firm belief that more can be done on the pre­ven­tion, pro­tec­tion, pros­e­cu­tion and part­ner­ship. As an exam­ple, togeth­er with IOM and UNODC, we set up 2 years ago a small pilot project with­out any ded­i­cat­ed resource, known as “fac­tors” to pick up from social media posts, includ­ing those orig­i­nat­ing from traf­fick­ers them­selves, who pub­li­cize their ran­som requests, inci­dents of human traf­fick­ing involv­ing migrants and refugees in Libya, Tchad, Niger and Sudan. We were able to doc­u­ment cas­es involv­ing more than 15,000 vic­tims. Refer­rals led in some instance to their release from traf­fick­ers, under­ground net­works. But not every­one was released, but no one can say today we didn’t know…?  These cas­es are known. Impuni­ty for the traf­fick­ers is no longer a cer­tain­ty. This small project illus­trates that we can do more with lit­tle and we should not give up, feel pow­er­less, con­front­ed to lose many chal­lenges. We can all con­tribute to a bet­ter response. What we need is less words and more focused action.

Thank you.

OUR MISSION:

THE PURPOSE IS TO SHARE BEST PRACTICES AND PROMOTE ACTIONS AGAINST HUMAN TRAFFICKING.

WE MAKE AVAILABLE TO YOU GUIDES AND RESEARCH ON TRAFFICKING IN HUMAN BEINGS FROM THE MOST RECOGNISED LEGAL AND OPERATIONAL ACTORS.

ADLAUDATOSI INTEGRAL ECOLOGY FORUM WEBINARS (WATCH THE REPLAY FOR PAST WEBINARS)

ADLAUDATOSI WEBINARS — LISTEN TO A SELECTION OF SPEAKERS’INTERVENTION IN MP3 (FOR LOW INTERNET DATA CONNEXION)

FABRICE HADJADJ — VIRTUAL AND REAL WORLDS: HOW TO INHABIT THE DEVASTATED EARTH?

AN EXAMPLE FOR CATHOLIC ENTITIES TO FOLLOW: ERADICATE MODERN SLAVERY IN ALL ITS FORMS FROM THE OPERATIONS AND SUPPLY CHAINS OF CATHOLIC ENTITIES IN AUSTRALIA — PROPOSAL OF ACTION PLAN – MODERN SLAVERY RISK MANAGEMENT PROGRAM FROM 2021 TO 30 JUNE 2023

Adlaudatosi Webinars Videos VIMEO

Videos of the speakers’ interventions adlaudatosi VIMEO

Adlaudatosi Webinars Videos YOUTUBE

Religious Helping Trafficking Victims along the Road of Recovery (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

Religious Working In International Advocacy Against Human Trafficking (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

Impact Of Human Trafficking On Health: Trauma (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

Impact Of Human Trafficking On Health: Healing (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

International Prosecution Of Human Trafficking — Where Are We Now? (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

International Prosecution Of Human Trafficking — What can be done? (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

International Prosecution Of Human Trafficking — Best Practices (ON-DEMAND VIDEO WEBINAR)

Demand As Root Cause For Human Trafficking – Sex Trafficking & Prostitution

Human Trafficking — Interview with Prof. Michel Veuthey, Order of Malta — 44th UN Human Right Council 2020

POPE’S PAYER INTENTION FOR FEBRUARY 2020: Hear the cries of migrants victims of human trafficking

FRANCE — BLOG DU COLLECTIF “CONTRE LA TRAITE DES ÊTRES HUMAINS”

Church on the frontlines in fight against human trafficking

Holy See — PUBLICATION OF PASTORAL ORIENTATIONS ON HUMAN TRAFFICKING 2019

RIGHT TO LIFE AND HUMAN DIGNITY GUIDEBOOK

Catholic social teaching

Doctrine sociale de l’Église catholique

Register to our series of webinars adlaudatosi on Human Trafficking

You have successfully registered !